Mansfield's Paul Bunyan dwarfed NFL

Mansfield Senior graduate Pete Henry is Ohio's only charter member of the College and Pro Football Hall of Fame. His first NFL season was 99 years ago this autumn. Today the Mansfield Senior gym is named in his honor.

EDITOR'S NOTE: This story was originally published April 24, 2019 by the Ohio History Connection. Ashland Source has entered into a collaborative agreement with the Ohio History Connection to share content across our sites.

The National Football League started as the American Professional Football Association in 1920. Ohio was home to five of the original teams: the Akron Pros, Canton Bulldogs, Cleveland Tigers, Columbus Panhandles and Dayton Triangles.

As the league marks its centennial, it should be noted five Ohio cities were involved that very first year.

Here’s a look back at Ohio’s NFL deep history and those five early, iconic teams.

Akron Pros

The Akron Pros were part of the NFL from the very beginning. They were one of 10 teams from four states representing regional leagues that met in Canton and formed the American Professional Football Association (APFA) on Sept. 17, 1920. The league would be renamed the National Football League two years later, in 1922.

Pros owner Art Ranney was elected secretary-treasurer of the league that day and minutes for the meeting were kept on his personal stationary. In all, 14 teams were part of the AFPAs first season including the Pros, Buffalo Prospects, Canton Bulldogs, Chicago Bears, Chicago Cardinals, Chicago Tigers, Cleveland Tigers (Indians), Columbus Panhandles, Dayton Triangles, Detroit Heralds, Hammond Pros, Muncie Flyers, Rochester Jeffersons, and Rock Island Independents.

The Pros were the APFAs first championship team and they did it without actually winning the championship game. After an 8-0-3 record in the inaugural season, The Pros held the Buffalo All-Americans to a scoreless tie in the final game. Because the Pros held the best record in the league, they only had to avoid losing the game, while Buffalo needed to win to earn the championship and the Brunswick-Balke-Collender Cup.

In 1921, the Pros were led by Fritz Pollard, the first black head coach in the NFL. Pollard is in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

Canton Bulldogs

The Canton Bulldogs, another of the original AFPA teams, set the NFL record for the most consecutive games played without a loss at 25 (including 3 ties), from 1921 to 23. The Bulldogs were NFL champions in 1922 and 1923, led by Mansfield's Pete Henry, a spectacular two-way lineman.

Without a doubt, the most famous player to play for the Bulldogs was Olympian Jim Thorpe, the first Native American to win a gold medal for the United States. Thorpe was also the league’s first president, but spent most of that first year playing for Canton. Ironically, he wasn't on those championship teams. Instead, Henry was the anchor of the Bulldogs.

Thorpe was replaced by the Columbus Panhandles’ Joseph Carr the next year.

In addition to Canton being the birthplace of the APFA, the Pro Football Hall of Fame said it selected Canton as its permanent hometown to recognize the Bulldogs' success in the league’s early seasons.

Six players from the Canton Bulldogs are enshrined in the NFL Hall of Fame, in addition to Henry and Thorpe: Guy Chamberlin, Joe Guyon, William "Link" Lyman, and Greasy Neale.

Cleveland Tigers

The Cleveland Tigers were also one of the 10 teams to join the APFA at the meeting in Canton in September, 1920. The Tigers did not enjoy much success in their first season, amassing only two touchdowns while compiling a record of 1–4–2.

Because Cleveland’s baseball team was the Indians and three Native Americans, including Thorpe, were signed away from the Canton Bulldogs to join the team in 1921, the squad changed its name to the Cleveland Indians in its second season. The team won its first two games in 1921 before Thorpe was lost for the season with injured ribs. The Indians lost four of the next five games in what would be their final season.

After recovering, Thorpe gathered a group of Native American players and started their own team, the Oorang Indians in LaRue, Ohio.

Fellow Native American, Joe Guyon, who played with Thorpe in both Cleveland and LaRue, joins Thorpe in the Hall of Fame, representing the Cleveland Indians.

Columbus Panhandles

While they have zero NFL championships, the Columbus Panhandles are credited with playing in the first game in the newly minted APFA (later named the NFL) on Oct. 3, 1920. That day the Panhandles lost 14–0 to the Dayton Triangles, at Triangle Park in Dayton. In the game, Frank Bacon of the Panhandles, was the first player in to return a punt for a touchdown.

In 1923, the Panhandles were renamed as the Columbus Tigers and played four more seasons before disbanding in 1926.

In its seven seasons, the Panhandles (Tigers) never finished higher than 8th in league standings.

There are no Panhandle players in the Hall of Fame, but Joseph Carr, the team's owner from 1907 to 1922, is enshrined for his work as NFL president. Carr moved the league headquarters to Columbus, Ohio, drafted the league constitution and by-laws, gave teams territorial rights, developed membership criteria for the franchises, and issued standings for the first time, so that there could be a clear champion.

Dayton Triangles

The Triangles 14-0 win over Columbus in that very first NFL game is the team’s claim to fame, but the high point of their 1920 season was a 20–20 tie at Triangle Park with Thorpe's Canton Bulldogs. It was the first time a team had scored three touchdowns versus the Bulldogs since 1915.

The Triangles are represented in the Hall of Fame by Greasy Neale, who also played baseball as an outfielder with the Cincinnati Reds.

Support Our Journalism

Local news coverage is only sustainable with local support. Here at Ashland Source, our stories will always be free to read, but they aren’t free to produce. Consider supporting our coverage of Ashland County by becoming a member today.