Editor’s Note

Ashland Source has a collaborative content agreement with the Ohio History Connection to share stories across our sites. This story was originally published on Aug. 2, 2013.

CLEVELAND — On Aug. 16, 1920, at the Polo Grounds in New York, Raymond Ray Chapman, star shortstop of the Cleveland Indians, stepped into the batter’s box in the fifth inning to face surly New York Yankees pitcher, Carl Mays.

Mays had an unorthodox delivery in that he threw under-hand, or submarine style, and had a reputation of throwing at batters. Chapman had a tendency to crowd the plate, and on the third pitch of the at-bat, on a 1-1 count, Mays threw a high fastball in Chapman’s direction, striking him in the head.

The sound of the ball coming off Chapman’s head was so loud that Mays thought the ball had hit Chapman’s bat, prompting him to field the ball and throw it to first base. Chapman’s knees buckled, dropping him to the ground in front of home plate.

Ray Chapman

Bloodied, he managed to stand up and began walking toward the clubhouse in center field, making it to second base before collapsing. Chapman was taken to St. Lawrence Hospital but would die 12 hours later on Aug. 17, 1920, making him the only Major League Baseball player to die as the result of being beaned, or hit by a pitch.

Newspapers available through the Library of Congress historic newspapers website, Chronicling America, allow you to follow the story of Ray Chapman and read articles about his career, death, and funeral.

Baseball was cherished by people during the time Ray Chapman played, and the newspapers covered the happenings on the diamond extensively. The Cleveland Indians went on to win their first World Series just a few months later on Oct. 12, 1920.

The players agreed to donate Chapman’s share of the bonus money to his pregnant widow, Kathleen Daly Chapman, a Cleveland native. Chapman told several people during the season that 1920 would be his last, as he wanted to start a family and work for his father-in-law, the President of the East Ohio Gas Company.

The tragedy of Chapman’s death did not end on the field. Kathleen Daly Chapman, a once avid baseball fan, never attended another baseball game.

She gave birth on Feb. 27, 1921, to Chapman’s daughter, Rae, but would eventually commit suicide from grief in 1926. Rae died from the measles in 1929.

Carl Mays could never endear himself to fans again, consistently blaming the accident on the condition of the baseball and swore until his death that the pitch was an accident. Mays lost his life savings in the stock market crash of 1929 and later lost his wife to an eye infection, leaving him alone with two children. When Mays died in 1971, the headline for his obituary read Carl Mays: Yankee Whose Pitch Killed Batter in 1920 is Dead.

Interested in learning more about Ray Chapman? Click here to see him featured in one of the Ohio Historical Society’s Chronicling America Search Strategy Videos available through YouTube! This short video will not only show you how to find information about Ray Chapman from the over six million pages of historic American newspapers available on Chronicling America, but it will teach you why you should use the date range search options when performing other searches on the website.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *