ASHLAND – It’s not often a football team with an 11-0 record hosting a second-round playoff game is considered an underdog.
Facing one of the most storied programs in Ohio history at Community Stadium on Friday night, Ashland had been hearing those whispers all week with Columbus St. Francis DeSales coming to town.
But after surrendering an opening-drive touchdown to the Stallions, the Arrows answered with one of the most impressive all-around performances in their 118-year history, collecting a 27-14 victory and tying the school record for most wins in a season.
“They’re athletic guys,” said AHS junior quarterback Nathan Bernhard, who ran for 130 yards and three touchdowns on 29 carries. “If you looked at them coming out of the tunnel, you would have thought they were going to beat us; they won the eye test. But the eye test doesn’t always tell everything and I think we were able to take what they gave us and make the most of it.”
“Everyone thought we were going to be the underdogs; we’re the smaller school,” added junior linebacker Gunner Lacey, who helped lead a defense that forced three turnovers for the fourth consecutive game. “… Coming out here, we showed them who we really are.”
The triumph clinched fourth-seeded Ashland (12-0) a spot in the Division II, Region 7 semifinals next Friday against top-seeded Big Walnut (11-1) at a neutral site to be determined. The Golden Eagles – ranked No. 8 in the division in the final AP state poll – rolled post Massillon Perry on Friday, 35-24, a game they led 35-10 early in the fourth quarter.
Ashland looked more than ready for its next challenge.
DeSales (9-3), which has nine state championship appearances in its history, scored on its first and last drives of the night.
In between that, the Arrows outscored the Stallions by a 27-0 count, annihilating DeSales in offensive plays run during that stretch, 59-19.
Ashland forced three punts and got a fumble recovery from Lacey after a big hit by Grayson Baith on a kickoff return to round out its first half.
That defensive effort helped send the Arrows to halftime with a 20-7 lead behind touchdown runs of 1 and 13 yards from Bernhard, and 2 yards from Baith. Junior kicker Carson O’Brien hit 3-of-4 PATs in the game, moving him past 100 career points scored.
In the second half, Ashland chewed up more than six minutes of clock on each of its first two drives. And even though the Arrows didn’t score on either of those, interceptions by sophomore Killian O’Brien and senior Josh Ingani helped spell the end for the Stallions.
DeSales quarterback R.J. Day – the son of Ohio State University head coach Ryan Day – came into Friday already carrying the program record for career passing yards (over 2,800).
But O’Brien picked him off near the AHS 30-yard line with the hosts holding a 20-7 lead late in the third quarter, and Ingani essentially clinched the win with his pick of Day on the Stallions’ next drive midway through the fourth.
“I should have returned it for a touchdown, but I gave our offense an opportunity to score, so I’m happy with that,” said Ingani, who returned his interception to the DeSales 10-yard line, setting up another 1-yard Bernhard score.
“We just stick to the fundamentals – don’t underestimate a team, don’t overestimate a team,” Killian O’Brien said. “We just came out here and played.”
Day finished 10-for-17 for 161 yards through the air, but the vast majority of that came on the Stallions’ first and last drives of the game.
Senior Bryce Herrick beat the Ashland defense deep for a 53-yard touchdown reception on the sixth play of the game. Day later was 5-of-5 for 65 yards on the team’s last drive, connecting with sophomore Dax Middleton (five catches for 57 yards) for a 15-yard score with 2:19 left in the fourth.
“We gave them the big (touchdown to Herrick) over the top and that’s just a mental mistake,” Arrows head coach Scott Valentine said. “Sometimes when you’re geeked up early in the game, you give up some like that.
“Our defense settled down and played well the rest of the game.”
DeSales running back Jonathan Brown – an explosive, 6-foot-1 junior who entered this season with NCAA Division I offers to play at Kent State and Eastern Kentucky – managed just 54 yards on 12 carries in the game.
In DeSales’ 48-28 first-round win over New Albany, Brown had 180 yards and three TDs on the ground. But his opportunities were limited with the Stallions playing catch-up most of the night.
Lacey, O’Brien, Ingani, Tyler Sauder, Cooper Smith and Gavin Hoffman led a defensive unit that posted yet another signature game one week after the first postseason shutout in program history (42-0 over St. Charles).
“Their (second drive of the game), that’s when we kicked it in gear,” Lacey said. “We came up and hit ‘em and they didn’t want to be hit.”
DeSales head coach Ryan Wiggins said the Arrows did a nice job of capitalizing on his team’s mistakes on both sides of the ball.
“They controlled the ball and limited our chances,” he said. “… You can tell they have good chemistry; they play together well.”
The Ashland secondary, in particular, continued a ferocious run against opposing quarterbacks over the last four games. During that stretch, the Arrows have 10 interceptions, as Ingani and Sauder lead the squad with four picks apiece this fall.
“We just got more comfortable making plays and we had a lot of guys returning (from last year),” Ingani said, “so the game slowed down for us and we’ve been able to read offenses more when we’re out there.
“It was a big emphasis this year that we had to get more turnovers on defense. We’ve gotten it done.”
In its last seven games, Ashland’s defense has forced 23 turnovers.
The other backbreaking stat for the Stallions on Friday was their inability to cut the Arrows’ drives short.
Ashland converted its first five fourth-down attempts in the game – twice on clutch completions from Bernhard (13-for-20 for 111 yards through the air) and two more times on runs by the junior QB.
He now has 200 carries and over 1,150 yards rushing this season.
“I was really worried about (Bernhard) because he can do it all,” Wiggins said. “Do you try to stop the run? Do you try to drop extra guys in coverage? It just seems to me that he can take about anything the defense is giving him.
“I think he’s as good as we’ve seen.”
Valentine said getting a big push from the offensive line of Joey Isenhart, Nolen Larue, Brandon Briggs, Smith and Gavin Chambers continued to be critical. Lacey and Tyler Holt also helped bolster the backfield on a few critical short-yardage plays.
“They were playing deep, so we weren’t going to get the deep, big plays – they were going to make us drive the field,” Valentine added. “(Bernhard) was patient taking it and our running (backs) were patient, getting yardage and getting us first downs.”
Baith continued to be a key change-of-pace running back for AHS, totaling 56 yards on 14 carries. His presence in the absence on offense of speedy senior back Michael Franz – who had a 39-yard reception in his return from injury to the offense Friday – has helped guide the Arrows for much of the season.
“Our line has given me everything,” Baith said. “They’re blocking really well, the coaches are calling the right plays and they’re opening things up for me. I just need to get it done.”
The next test for the Arrows will be Big Walnut, a team that has won 11 straight since a 20-0 season-opening loss to Division III AP state poll champ Bishop Watterson (12-0).
Like Ashland, the Golden Eagles have a pair of shutouts this season and have shown they can score at will – totaling at least 31 points in 10 of their 11 wins.
A win next week for the Arrows would set a program record and send them into a regional title game for the first time since 2010.
“We’ve got a chance to become the winningest team in Ashland High School history,” Bernhard said. “We’ve got a lot of things in front of us and we’re excited.”
Also in the OCC
Ashland wasn’t the only Ohio Cardinal Conference team to advance Friday night, as the league’s remaining teams were a perfect 3-0 in the second round.
In Division III, Region 10, No. 12 seed Lexington (7-5) bounced No. 4 seed Rocky River (8-4), 49-29. The Minutemen now face top-seeded and No. 2 state-ranked Toledo Central Catholic (11-1) next week.
In Division IV, Region 15, No. 13 seed West Holmes (7-5) topped No. 12 seed East Liverpool (7-5), 24-13. The Knights advanced to play top-seeded and No. 5 state-ranked St. Clairsville (12-0) next week.
(These photos are courtesy of Lukas Christian)











