ASHLAND — About 60 buckets are currently scattered throughout the Ashland County Jail to contain leaks from the facility’s roof failures.
The county jail opened in February 2001. Leaks in the roof have been a reality since 2002, according to county officials.
The Ashland County Board of Commissioners on Oct. 29 approved an estimate (not to exceed) of $3,595,675 from The Garland Company, Inc., a Cleveland-based material manufacturer, for significant renovations to the roof.
This did not mean a contract was signed or the project was approved to proceed.
According to Ohio Revised Code Section 153.36, repairs or improvements related to a county courthouse or jail that exceed $75,000 in costs require approval from a four-member committee consisting of the county common pleas court clerk, sheriff, probate judge and one person to be appointed by the common pleas court judge.
In this instance, the committee included Deborah Myers (clerk), Ashland County Sheriff Kurt Schneider, Ashland County Juvenile and Probate Judge Karen DeSanto Kellogg and Common Pleas Court Judge David Stimpert.
A majority approval from committee members (three of four) is necessary for these projects, including the roof renovations, to proceed, according to ORC.
County commissioners organized a special meeting Tuesday morning for this committee to gather, along with representatives from Garland. The meeting was open to the public.
Following a nearly 90-minute discussion, a roll call vote to approve the project was conducted among committee members and commissioners.
Myers, Schneider and Stimpert each approved the project during the vote. Kellogg had to excuse herself before the vote was taken due to her judgeship responsibilities.
Commissioners Denny Bittle, Michael Welch and Jim Justice each reaffirmed their approval to proceed with the renovations.
According to the board, formal approval of the proposed contract with Garland may be presented as early as Thursday during commissioners’ next regularly scheduled meeting.
In order to lock in current proposed pricing, the contract needs to be approved before the end of the year, according to commissioners.
DETAILS ON THE PLANNED ROOF RENOVATION EFFORTS
Questions, comments and concerns raised
Kellogg emphasized the importance of making sure whatever work is done to the roof be done properly.
Her questions largely echoed that sentiment, centering around technical aspects of the roof renovations themselves, as well as contract-related inquiries.
She asked whether or not the county’s legal counsel had reviewed the proposed contract, as well as if the county’s engineer reviewed any of the proposed plans and/or offered an opinion.
Steve Wrona, a Garland territory manager, said the county prosecutor reviewed the contract.
Commissioners said the county engineer had not reviewed the proposed renovations, but cited the county’s lengthy history with and trust in Garland.
Garland has handled projects with Ashland County for more than 20 years, specifically efforts to maintain county buildings — including roofing and walls. Wrona himself has worked with the county for the past decade.
While not a member of the four-member oversight committee, commissioner-elect Brandon Carpenter asked about the warranty length and coverage percentage on the planned renovations.
Wrona said it’s a 30-year warranty and covers roughly 99% of the roof’s surface. He said he sees no reason why the renovated roof should not last for at least 30 to 40 years into the future.
Carpenter also made inquiries into the board’s selection process to go with Garland for the project. Wrona said local contractors participated in an installation bidding process.
Garland handles the bidding of its subcontractors, he said.
Kellogg cited a concern with the contract related to the contractor’s ability to do work without first receiving specific, formal written approval from the board. She also inquired about a construction milestone schedule, beyond simply an estimated completion date (which currently is listed as July 1, 2027, according to the contract).
Wrona said a more detailed construction schedule is something that could be provided.
“My obvious concern isn’t to tell you (the board) how to build a roof for the sheriff (or) how to run his jail,” Kellogg said. “To be transparent, I want to make sure that there’s some money to fix up our courthouse and some real needs that are there.”
Below is a full recording of Tuesday’s special meeting.
Delays to courthouse renovations likely, says board
Funding the nearly $3.6 million project will include $700,000 from the county jail operations fund. The remaining $2,895,675 will come from the county’s capital projects fund, with jail operations responsible for repaying that advanced amount.
The arrangement calls for annual payments from the jail of at least $100,000 by Oct. 31 until the advance is repaid back into the county’s capital projects fund. Welch estimated the sheriff’s repayment plan to last about 30 years, possibly less.
Schneider previously said the county will monitor sales tax revenue and could make larger payments if funds allow.
Four percent of the county’s sales tax revenue is allocated monthly to the capital projects fund, Welch said, another stream of replenishing the fund along with the sheriff’s repayment plan.
County Auditor Cindy Funk said the sales tax generates a minimum of $475,000 annually for the capital projects fund (or at least $30,000 per month minimum).
During previous discussions, the board considered completing the renovations in sections but ultimately determined the cost savings were too good to pass up with completing the work in one shot.
According to the board, completing the project as a whole will save an estimated $400,000 to $500,000.
But the roof renovations ultimately mean a delay in renovations to the courthouse.
Bittle said the courthouse project will not move forward until the dollars are available. A total estimate on that project is not available yet as final plans and engineering work are still being finalized.
Bittle estimated that work may be completed by mid-to-late 2027, with a potential project start date of 2028.
But it all depends on the state of the capital projects fund balance. Justice didn’t mince words.
“I’m going to be a little more blunt. This was money we could have used on the courthouse,” he said. “I wish that we didn’t have this issue, but if the courthouse were leaking we’d have to fix that, too.”
He said the roof renovations can’t be kicked down the road any longer.
While Myers voiced her disappointment in delays to courthouse renovations, she said she also understood the county’s responsibility to take care of the jail facility. Stimpert shared similar sentiments.
“It is what it is,” he said. “I mean, you’ve got to fix the roof… can’t have 60 buckets (collecting leaks).”
