ASHLAND – A good pie takes time, patience and practice, something Lyn-Way Restaurant has certainly mastered over the last 75 years.
Since first opening its doors in 1951, the family-owned Ashland staple has offered generations of regulars more than just a home-cooked meal. It’s given them a place to gather and a slice of pie worth saving room for.
🥧 Bite Club Quick Take
Perfect for: A homestyle meal, families and anyone who loves a good slice of pie.
Don’t miss: The homemade pies. My favorites were the Buckeye, graham cracker and banana, but there’s plenty to choose from. Add a scoop of ice cream if you can.
Vibe: A fresh, bright take on the classic family diner, blending a clean, updated dining room with vintage photos, longtime menu favorites and 75 years of history.
Worth the drive: Absolutely, especially if you’re a pie lover or looking for a taste of old-fashioned Ashland.
Address: 1320 Cleveland Ave., Ashland, OH 44805
Hours: Tuesday through Thursday, 8 a.m. to 7 p.m.; Friday and Saturday, 8 a.m. to 7:30 p.m. Closed Sunday and Monday. Breakfast is served Tuesday through Saturday, 8 a.m. to noon.

A little slice of heaven
With more than 20 varieties listed on the website, from traditional apple pie to Dutch peach à la mode and sour cream raisin, the selection offers something for just about every kind of pie lover. In addition to everyday staples, the bakery also turns out lesser-known, seasonal varieties, such as ground cherry and elderberry pies, made using fresh fruit sourced from the local Amish community.
During my visit, I ordered a bit of everything and ended up with a table full of options. As someone who usually only orders pie as an excuse to eat a small mountain of whipped cream, I was surprised by how much I enjoyed these.

My favorite was the Buckeye pie, which paired a pudding-like chocolate filling with a taste of peanut butter that came through toward the end. It was topped with whipped cream and a crumble, satisfying a chocolate craving without being overly rich.

The graham cracker pie was another favorite. Its light, vanilla filling was layered over a graham cracker crust and topped with a generous layer of whipped cream and more graham cracker crumble. It was less sweet than some of the other options, making it a nice choice for anyone looking to end their meal on a lighter note.

The banana pie immediately brought back one of my earliest Lyn-Way memories: ordering their banana milkshake as a kid and being thrilled that it was made with real fruit instead of artificial syrup. Lyn-Way’s pie tastes like genuine, homemade banana pudding, with banana slices inside a traditional crust.

The pumpkin pie was next, a true Thanksgiving favorite. It had a smooth filling and a thick dollop of whipped cream. It was a milder take on the traditional fall favorite, which may appeal to those who prefer a more subtle flavor.


Lastly, the fruit pies offered a welcome contrast in flavors. Both the Dutch cherry and Dutch blackberry had a nice balance of tartness and sweetness, making them a bright option if the cream pies aren’t your thing. I especially enjoyed the buttery streusel topping, which added a crumbly texture to each bite. We got ours served warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. For me, any dessert served with ice cream gets bonus points.
One detail I appreciated across each the pies was the crust. I’m usually the person scraping the filling out and leaving the crust behind, but Lyn-Way’s was flaky, lightly buttery and had just a bit of salt. I actually ate it and enjoyed it, which might be the biggest compliment I can give to any pie maker.
A family story, 75 years in the making

When owner Rob Stoops’ grandfather, Merle Plank, and his wife, Frances, turned an old gas station into a 44-seat diner on June 7, 1951, they started with coffee, curb service and five or six pies a day baked by Merle’s mother. Four factories sat behind the lot back then, and workers crossed the street on break for a slice and a familiar face.
Those factories are gone, but the restaurant is still serving the community much the same way it did in 1951. After his mother, Janet Stoops, retired in 2025 following more than five decades leading the restaurant, Rob and his wife, Chris, took over the family business.
Rob describes Lyn-Way as a gathering place where families don’t have to navigate a bar scene or feel rushed out the door. Fourth-generation regulars still fill the dining room, and former locals who moved as far away as Arizona still make visitng Lyn-Way a priority when visiting home, hoping the case holds a slice of pie their grandmother used to order.
“They come in and go, ‘I just want a piece of pie, because my grandma used to have this,'” Rob said. “You don’t get that at too many other places.”
The familiarity extends beyond the bakery. While the kitchen occasionally adds new sandwiches or specials, longtime staples like liver and onions, still one of Lyn-Way’s top-selling dinners, remain on the menu alongside hand-cut lettuce, macaroni salad, potato salad and coleslaw, all made using the same recipes since the beginning.
The people behind the pie
That sense of family starts with how Rob treats the people working behind the counter. While high turnover is the norm across the restaurant industry, 13 of Lyn-Way’s roughly 50 employees have more than 300 years of combined service, including servers who have spent more than four decades greeting regulars by name.
Rob works around high schoolers’ schedules so they can still be kids, welcomes college students back on holiday breaks, and gives his staff room to bring their own ideas to the table. That might mean letting college-age servers add trendy “dirty sodas” to the menu or bakers experimenting with new flavors, like grape or Whatchamacallit candy-inspired pies.
“It’s the employees, diehards who come in here and run their tails off, that make this place run,” Rob said. “If we didn’t have them, we wouldn’t be here today.”
That dedication is especially evident during this time of year, when longtime pie makers Jana Fleming and Tammy Fawcett ramp up from their usual 25 to 30 daily pies, mixing timeless family recipes with creative specials, to send roughly 500 holiday pies onto Ashland dinner tables.
“They come in at about midnight on the 24th, and they bake all night long, all day long, and make all those pies,” Rob said. “I’ve got two pie makers. They’ve both been with me for quite a few years and they just bust them out.”
If you’re reading this before Tuesday, November 24, you might still be able to place your Thanksgiving pie order. Visit Lyn-Way’s site for details.
Traditional family restaurants like Lyn-Way are becoming harder to find, especially as the restaurant landscape changes. For 75 years, this Ashland staple has proved that good food, a dedicated crew and genuine hospitality never go out of style.
Whether you stop in for the scratch-made pies or the familiar faces behind the counter, Lyn-Way still makes you feel like there is always a place for you at the table.









MORE FROM BITE CLUB
Bite Club: Is Food Land Minimart Mansfield’s best hidden gem?
MANSFIELD — One of my favorite parts of writing Bite Club is discovering places I have driven past for years without ever really knowing what was inside. Food Land Minimart is a perfect example. It’s less than 10 minutes from my office, and I’ve driven past it more times than I can count, and until…
Skip the dinner debate: Savor & Sip brings 20+ local food and drink spots together
MANSFIELD – If your household is anything like mine, most evenings include some form of that exhausting “I don’t know, what do you want to eat?” debate. On Thursday, Oct. 22, the Richland Area Chamber & Economic Development is solving the dinner problem while giving you a fun way to support local businesses.
Bite Club: Carbs done right and a story worth savoring at Bucci’s Italian Scratch Kitchen
Discover Bucci’s Italian Scratch Kitchen in Marion, where short rib tortellini, fried mozzarella and warm service make dinner worth the drive.
