ASHLAND — The Ashland County Board of Commissioners approved Thursday a $3.6 million contract for renovations to the county jail roof.

However, concerns related to the project are not limited to the more than two decades worth of leaks in the roof, according to a county judge.

The board approved the contract with Garland/DBS, Inc. for roof repairs at the county sheriff’s office and jail in an amount not to exceed $3,595,675.

Commissioners could not proceed with approving the contract without first receiving a majority approval from a four-member review committee — Ashland County Sheriff Kurt Schneider, Juvenile and Probate Judge Karen DeSanto Kellogg, Common Pleas Court Judge David Stimpert and Clerk of Courts Deborah Myers.

Ohio Revised Code Section 153.36, requires a majority committee approval for repairs or improvements related to a county courthouse or jail that exceed $75,000 in costs in order for these projects to commence.

Schneider thanked Kellogg prior to the vote Thursday for her help in getting the review committee to meet.

“At least for my sake, it was a little bit of an oversight on what that statute really read,” he said. “But I’m grateful that she had her eyes on things and she does a diligent job for the community and the county and brought that to our attention.

“Otherwise, we could have probably got ourselves in a little bit of trouble, so I’m thankful that she did that.”

The four-member committee met during a special meeting Tuesday alongside commissioners. Representatives from Garland, a Cleveland-based material manufacturer, were also present to answer questions and present project information.

After a nearly 90-minute discussion, a roll call vote to approve the project was conducted among committee members and commissioners. Myers, Schneider and Stimpert each approved the project during the vote.

Kellogg excused herself before the vote due to court responsibilities.

Commissioners Denny Bittle, Michael Welch and Jim Justice each reaffirmed their approval to proceed with the renovations. In order to lock in current proposed pricing, the contract needed formal approval before the end of the year, the board said Tuesday.

Funding will come from the county jail operations fund ($700,000) and the county’s capital projects fund ($2,895,675). Jail operations will be responsible for repaying that advanced amount from the capital projects fund over a 30-year period.

The arrangement calls for annual payments from the jail of at least $100,000 by Oct. 31 each year until the advance is repaid. Commissioners and Schneider both stated the repayment plan may not take three decades if funds allow for larger repayments.

No outside funds are being borrowed or bonded for the project. According to the board, completing the project as a whole (versus segments) will save an estimated $400,000 to $500,000.

The county jail opened in February 2001. Leaks in the roof have been a reality since 2002, according to county officials.

Kellogg pens letter sharing concerns

During Tuesday’s meeting, Kellogg emphasized the importance of making sure whatever work is done to the roof be done properly. Her questions centering around technical aspects of the roof renovations themselves, as well as contract-related inquiries.

Following the special meeting, the commissioners’ office contacted Kellogg and asked her to respond with her vote so it could be recorded in the meeting minutes.

Kellogg sent a letter Wednesday to commissioners, Schneider and her fellow members on the review committee. She said the letter served as her response to the vote request.

“It sums up many of my concerns,” Kellogg told Ashland Source on Thursday.

“My concerns are not about opposing the sheriff, the review committee, or the need to
maintain the jail,” Kellogg wrote at the opening of the letter.

“They are about the Board of Commissioners’ decision to plan and advance a multimillion-dollar capital project without meaningfully involving the elected officials whose operations and facilities will be affected, and then seek the approval required by law at the last minute without presenting a comprehensive plan for the county’s overall facility needs,” Kellogg said.

The judge highlighted three core concerns:

  • No demonstrated emergency requiring immediate action on the jail roof has been presented.
  • There is no comprehensive capital facilities plan.
  • Opportunities for meaningful participation have not been provided.

Related to the roof, Kellogg said she’s not convinced there is an immediate urgency requiring the renovations to move forward before the county “has fully evaluated its options.”

“To date, I have not received a professional assessment establishing that delaying the project will result in additional structural or operational problems,” she wrote. “Before committing several million dollars, I believe we are entitled to that information.”

Welch, who serves as board president, said on Thursday afternoon the county has completed several previous roof projects with Garland — which has handled projects with Ashland County for more than 20 years, specifically efforts to maintain county buildings — including roofing and walls.

“We can’t sit on our hands and do nothing,” Welch told Ashland Source on Thursday, explaining leaks in the roof have increased the threat of collateral damage to electrical systems and the environment within the jail/sheriff’s office.

The board said Tuesday that it maintains a five-year roof plan. It’s reviewed annually.

The roof renovations ultimately mean a delay in renovations to the county courthouse.

Below is a letter courtesy of Juvenile and Probate Judge Karen DeSanto Kellogg. The judge shared this letter Wednesday with commissioners and Schneider, along with the two additional review committee members.

Outside of the roof renovation, Kellogg cited a greater concern — the absence of a comprehensive capital facilities improvement and management plan that includes the courthouse.

“The county has now constructed an over $6 million administration building to relocate
four offices. Yet there remains no concrete plan or financing strategy for accomplishing the Board’s broader goal of moving nonjudicial functions out of the courthouse and addressing the courthouse’s long-term needs,” she wrote.

“A concrete plan and financial strategy are part of fiscal responsibility. We cannot continue to call something a priority without developing and committing to a plan to accomplish it.”

Welch emphasized the board’s firm standing on not taking on projects that would require the county to borrow or bond money.

“We have to fix the problem,” he said regarding the roof renovations.

Kellogg also described the manner in which the vote was taken Tuesday as “troubling.”

She said the board proceeded while knowing in advance she could not be present because she had a court docket scheduled to begin.

“Calling for a vote under those circumstances deprived me of the opportunity to hear the discussion, ask questions in real time and have meaningful input before a decision was made,” she wrote.

“I believe that was unfortunate and raises legitimate questions about the fairness and appropriateness of the process, including whether the action taken was procedurally valid.”

She closed by asking commissioners to develop and present a comprehensive, financially grounded capital facilities improvement and management plan that includes the jail, courthouse, administration building and the county’s other facility needs.

“Our responsibility is not simply to find money for the next project. It is to make sound
decisions today that protect the county’s ability to meet its obligations tomorrow,” Kellogg wrote.

Staff reporter at Source Media Properties since 2023. Shelby High School/Kent State alum. Have a story to share? Email me at hayden@ashlandsource.com.